Mitchell Broodley’s “Overtime Again” touches us like a chapter taken from real life, torn straight out of the notebook of someone who’s lived a few different lives already. Raised in South Carolina, now settled in Vermont with a law career, hospital leadership, and a family under his belt, Broodley isn’t chasing the country dream so much as circling back to it—with more miles, more scars, and a lot more perspective.
After his surprise holiday hit climbed Amazon’s charts, “Overtime Again” leans into what he does best: honest, lived-in storytelling wrapped in modern country warmth. This time, the field he’s playing on is a long-distance relationship, where every visit feels like the last two minutes of the fourth quarter.
The track opens on a gentle glow of glistening acoustic guitars, a warm melody settling in like porch light at dusk. Broodley’s soft, steady, unmistakably Southern voice drops you right into the room as he remembers, “You walked in wearing my old jersey, hair in a ponytail, blocking the TV,” turning a simple image into a whole relationship in one frame. It’s football as emotional shorthand, not a gimmick: the game on the screen, the real stakes sitting beside him on the couch.
When the chorus hits, the drums rumble in quietly, and the guitars begin to splash and sparkle, widening the sound. He leans into that storytelling tone, almost talking more than singing as he confesses, “Laughing and kissing, holding you tight, every second counts… Tomorrow I will be gone again, replaying every moment that we’ve spent.” It’s not about grand promises, just the ache of knowing the clock is always running.
“Overtime Again” feels genuinely true. It’s the sound of a man who’s already walked away from music once and decided, with clear eyes, that this time every song has to be worth staying for.
STAY IN TOUCH:
FACEBOOK | INSTAGRAM | SPOTIFY | TIKTOK | WEBSITE | YOUTUBE
Review by: Naomi Joan